Naked Swimmer Accused of Killing Security Guard

Legend Storer, 20, pleaded not guilty after police linked him to the fatal overnight attack through condominium security footage.

WAILUKU, Hawaii — A 20-year-old champion swimmer accused of killing a security guard at a West Maui condominium complex while naked pleaded not guilty to murder and other charges Friday and was ordered held without bail as the case moves forward.

Legend Storer of Lahaina faces charges of second-degree murder, first-degree burglary and indecent exposure in the death of 63-year-old Michael Dyer, who worked as a security guard at the Sands of Kahana condominium complex. Authorities say surveillance footage showed Storer entering Dyer’s office and attacking him at about 1:45 a.m. Wednesday, Aug. 5. Police later found Storer walking naked in the surrounding area before Dyer was discovered unresponsive several hours later.

Maui police said officers encountered Storer at about 3:30 a.m. after reports of a naked man in the area. He had numerous abrasions and was taken to Maui Memorial Medical Center for an evaluation. At that point, authorities had not yet connected him to Dyer’s death. Police were called to the condominium complex at about 5:30 a.m., where officers found Dyer dead inside the security office.

Investigators later reviewed surveillance footage from the property and identified Storer as the person they allege attacked Dyer. Court records cited by Hawaii News Now say Storer may have used a five-gallon water bottle during the assault. Authorities have not publicly released the full surveillance recording, and the allegations against Storer have not been proven in court.

Dyer was working overnight when the attack occurred. Bell Hill, a co-worker, told local news outlets that Dyer had been eating during his break when he was attacked. Hill described him as a good person and said his death had devastated those who knew him. Dyer’s family later issued a statement describing him as a devoted husband to his wife, Joy, and said relatives were dealing with the sudden loss.

Storer appeared Friday before District Court Judge Christopher Dunn. He entered not guilty pleas to the charges. Dunn ordered him held without bail, saying he could not identify release conditions that would reasonably guarantee Storer’s appearance in court or protect the community. Storer was being held at the Maui Community Correctional Center and was scheduled to return to court Aug. 11.

Dyer’s age could also become a factor as prosecutors pursue the case. Hawaii has enhanced penalties that can apply to certain crimes committed against people age 60 or older. Prosecutors had not announced any additional charge tied to that provision as of Sunday, and the precise penalties Storer could face will depend on the charges that ultimately proceed and the outcome of the case.

Before his arrest, Storer had built a record as a competitive swimmer. Concordia University Irvine listed him as a freshman on its 2024-25 men’s swimming and diving roster. The university profile said he graduated from Maui Preparatory Academy in 2024 and had been a two-time Maui Interscholastic League champion. His athletic background became part of widespread coverage after police identified him in the homicide investigation.

Authorities have not publicly identified a motive for the alleged attack or explained whether Dyer and Storer knew each other before that night. The available court and police accounts describe surveillance evidence and the sequence in which officers encountered Storer and later found Dyer, but investigators have not released a complete account of what they believe led to the confrontation.

The death has unsettled residents around Kahana, where the condominium property sits along West Maui’s resort corridor. Local residents told news outlets they heard unusual shouting during the early morning hours. Police have not established publicly whether every reported disturbance was connected to the killing, and witness accounts remain separate from evidence that prosecutors will need to establish in court.

Storer remains presumed innocent unless proven guilty. He is being held without bail while the prosecution continues, with his next court appearance scheduled for Aug. 11. Investigators have not announced a motive, and additional details about the evidence are expected to emerge through the court process.

Author note: Last updated August 9, 2026.