Woman Killed During Video Call as Family Watches in Horror

A relative contacted 911 after a troubling video conversation with Dawn Capstick, leading deputies to her Festus-area home.

FESTUS, Mo. — A Missouri man has been charged with first-degree murder and armed criminal action after authorities said his 56-year-old wife was fatally shot at their home while she was on a video call with a family member.

Todd M. Capstick, 55, is accused of killing Dawn M. Capstick on Nov. 5 at a residence in the 3100 block of U.S. Highway 61 south of Festus. The case began with a welfare-check request from a relative who told authorities that troubling events had unfolded during a video conversation with Dawn. Deputies later found her in a bedroom with multiple apparent gunshot wounds. Todd Capstick was arrested in Cape Girardeau County about an hour after the investigation began, according to law enforcement officials and court records cited by news organizations.

The family member told investigators that something was said about a shooting during the video call before Dawn’s phone appeared to be lying on the floor, according to a probable cause statement. Todd Capstick then briefly appeared on the screen before the call was muted and paused. The relative disconnected and called 911, prompting the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office to send a deputy to the couple’s home.

The deputy arrived at about 9:15 a.m. and found Dawn in a bedroom with what authorities described as multiple gunshot wounds. The deputy and emergency medical workers attempted lifesaving measures, but she was pronounced dead at the scene. Investigators reported finding several shell casings in the bedroom. Authorities have not publicly announced a motive, and the criminal allegations against Todd Capstick have not been proven in court.

Investigators also reviewed security-camera footage from the residence. According to the probable cause statement, the footage showed Dawn entering the home through the garage with Todd following her. About 22 minutes later, investigators said, Todd was recorded leaving through the garage while carrying a black-and-silver handgun. He placed the weapon in his clothing before getting into a black Ford truck and driving away, authorities alleged.

Investigators used traffic-camera information to follow the truck as it traveled south on Interstate 55. After the vehicle was detected heading through Ste. Genevieve County, the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office asked the U.S. Marshals Service for help. Marshals located the vehicle in Cape Girardeau County and conducted a traffic stop shortly after 10 a.m., about an hour after deputies were first sent to the Festus-area home.

Todd Capstick was taken into custody during the traffic stop. Investigators said a handgun was recovered from the vehicle. Court documents cited by People also said he had a large amount of cash when he was located. Authorities have not publicly said what significance, if any, they believe the money has to the homicide investigation.

The Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office charged Capstick with first-degree murder and armed criminal action. He was ordered held without bond in the Jefferson County Jail. Law&Crime reported that he had been arraigned and was scheduled to return to court Nov. 30. Publicly available records reviewed by People on Nov. 12 did not show a plea at that time.

The killing was among a series of homicide investigations handled by the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office this year. The Leader reported that Dawn’s death was the 14th death connected to 12 homicide investigations handled by the department in 2026. Authorities have said the investigation into her death remains active.

Dawn’s relatives remembered her as a mother, teacher, athlete and animal lover who also enjoyed sewing, writing and reading. Her family described her as energetic and devoted to the people close to her. Todd Capstick remains in custody as the criminal case proceeds, and investigators have not publicly identified a confirmed motive.

Author note: Last updated November 14, 2026.