Man Stabbed Young Mom 120 Times

DNA evidence helped revive the decades-old Illinois cold case that ended with James Barbier’s first-degree murder conviction.

CALUMET CITY, Ill. — Nearly 60 years after 18-year-old Karen Snider was killed inside her suburban Chicago home while her infant daughter was nearby, a jury has convicted longtime family friend James Barbier of first-degree murder.

Barbier, 81, was found guilty Nov. 9 in Snider’s Nov. 12, 1966, killing in Calumet City. Snider suffered more than 120 stab wounds, according to prosecutors and police records cited during the case. Her 2-month-old daughter, Paula, was found unharmed in a bassinet. Barbier, who had been considered a suspect shortly after the killing but was not charged at the time, is scheduled to be sentenced Dec. 15.

Snider was at home while her husband, Paul Snider, was working at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad when she was killed, prosecutors said. Barbier was a friend of the couple and worked with Paul Snider. Prosecutors argued at trial that Barbier knew the husband’s work schedule and was able to enter the home because Karen Snider knew him.

Paul Snider returned home at about 11 p.m. and found his wife dead, according to accounts from the original investigation. Their baby daughter was nearby but had not been harmed. Investigators initially had limited physical evidence and focused attention on Barbier after witnesses noticed injuries on him around the time of Snider’s funeral. Barbier also served as a pallbearer at the funeral.

Prosecutors said Barbier’s wife at the time reported that he appeared nervous when he returned home on the night of the killing and had blood and cuts on him. She also told authorities that he quickly placed his clothes in a washing machine, behavior she considered unusual. Barbier was arrested during the original investigation, but authorities did not have enough evidence to prosecute him and he was released.

The case remained unresolved for decades. Calumet City detectives reopened the investigation after receiving a call in 2022 from a man who remembered his grandmother discussing the case. Investigators reviewed preserved evidence and submitted clothing connected to Snider for modern DNA testing.

Prosecutors said testing of blood evidence produced a DNA profile linked to Barbier. ABC7 Chicago reported that the testing showed a significant likelihood that blood stains on Snider’s clothing matched his DNA. The evidence led authorities to arrest Barbier at his home in Creve Coeur, Missouri, in spring 2024. He was 79 at the time.

At trial, prosecutors relied on the DNA findings along with testimony and circumstances from the original investigation. The defense challenged the strength of the genetic evidence, arguing that the decades-old samples were incomplete and that Barbier’s status as a family friend could explain why his DNA might have been present in the home. Jurors ultimately found him guilty of first-degree murder after deliberating for about two hours.

Snider’s daughter, now an adult, had spent nearly her entire life without knowing whether anyone would be held criminally responsible for her mother’s death. Her father died in 1989, decades before investigators developed the evidence that led to Barbier’s prosecution. The conviction came just days before the 60th anniversary of the killing.

Barbier has not yet been sentenced. Court proceedings are expected to continue with post-trial matters before his Dec. 15 sentencing, when the judge will determine the punishment for the first-degree murder conviction.