Man Mails Peanut Butter Card to Woman With Deadly Allergy

Police say investigators traced the mailing through postage records after the recipient suffered an allergic reaction in August 2025.

PLANTATION, Fla. — A 68-year-old Florida man has been charged after police said he deliberately mailed a greeting card smeared with peanut butter to a woman whose severe allergy could make exposure life-threatening.

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. was arrested Nov. 13 and charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence exposing another person to harm, according to a Plantation Police Department probable cause affidavit cited by multiple news organizations. Investigators allege Cancellare knew about the woman’s severe peanut allergy and sent the card intending to expose her to a substance that could cause serious injury or death. The woman, whose name has not been publicly released in the reports reviewed, is the best friend of Cancellare’s former wife.

The case began Aug. 14, 2025, when the woman returned home from work and found a blue envelope that appeared greasy, according to the affidavit. Police said she did not recognize the handwriting and opened the envelope to find a greeting card with a brown substance spread across it. The woman recognized the substance as peanut butter, dropped the envelope and went inside to wash her hands. Investigators said she later developed hives on both arms and experienced tingling for about six hours.

The woman told investigators that her peanut allergy is severe and can affect her breathing, according to the arrest documents. Police said medical records reviewed during the investigation supported the seriousness of her condition, and a previous police report from 2017 also documented the allergy. Authorities allege Cancellare had known the woman for roughly two decades and had repeatedly seen her take precautions to avoid peanuts when the families socialized, including while eating at restaurants.

Investigators worked with a U.S. postal inspector to trace two Forever stamps attached to the envelope, according to the affidavit. The stamps were purchased Aug. 8, 2025, from a self-service kiosk at a post office in Davie. Police said investigators determined that a Visa card belonging to Cancellare had been used in the transaction. A camera at the kiosk also captured an image of the person buying the stamps, according to police.

The woman identified Cancellare when investigators showed her the kiosk image, the affidavit states. Other people familiar with him also identified him in the photograph, according to police. Authorities said the stamps were processed through a Miami postal facility on Aug. 13, one day before the woman received the envelope. Investigators also alleged that the mailing used a fictitious sender name and a false return address.

Police said the relationship between Cancellare and the woman provided additional context for the investigation. The woman told detectives that Cancellare had been married to her best friend and that their divorce had been contentious. According to investigators, she said Cancellare largely blamed her for the breakup. She told police that her last direct interaction with him had been in July 2022, when she was present during the division of property connected to the divorce settlement.

An acquaintance of Cancellare and his former wife also spoke with investigators, according to the arrest affidavit. Police said the acquaintance told detectives that Cancellare knew how serious the woman’s allergy was and had previously made remarks about wanting to harm people connected to the divorce, including the woman. Those statements are allegations contained in the police investigation and have not been proven in court.

The investigation continued for more than a year as detectives gathered witness statements, medical documentation and postal records. Police arrested Cancellare at his Plantation home on Nov. 13, according to the affidavit. He was taken to a hospital for medical clearance before being booked into the Broward Sheriff’s Office jail. Local 10 reported that his bond had been set at $20,000 as of Saturday morning.

Law&Crime and People reported Sunday that Cancellare had since posted bond. His next court date was not listed in the reports reviewed, and it was not immediately clear whether he had an attorney representing him in the criminal case. The charges remain allegations, and Cancellare is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.