Father ‘Hunted Down’ Stepson Before Fatal Shooting

Prosecutors said William Bryan Morgan armed himself and went looking for Caleb Donnelly after deputies responded repeatedly to a family dispute.

GREENWOOD, S.C. — A South Carolina man was sentenced to 30 years in prison after a jury convicted him of murdering his adult stepson following a series of domestic disturbances at the family’s Greenwood County property in June 2021, prosecutors said.

William Bryan Morgan, 36, was found guilty of murder Nov. 18 in the death of 29-year-old Caleb Donnelly, according to the Eighth Judicial Circuit Solicitor’s Office. Jurors deliberated for about two hours after an eight-day trial. Circuit Judge Thomas William McGee III imposed a 30-year prison sentence that prosecutors said must be served day for day with no possibility of parole.

The case began when Greenwood County sheriff’s deputies were called to a dispute involving Morgan and Donnelly at a party at another residence, prosecutors said. Deputies eventually took Donnelly back to a small converted outbuilding behind Morgan’s home where Donnelly lived. Authorities said the move was intended to separate the men and calm the situation.

Deputies were called back a short time later after Donnelly damaged property inside Morgan’s residence, according to the solicitor’s office. While deputies spoke with Donnelly’s mother, Morgan returned to the property, retrieved a .357 Magnum revolver and went looking for his stepson, prosecutors said.

At the time, deputies told Donnelly’s mother they believed they had enough evidence to obtain an arrest warrant for the property damage. Prosecutors said officers expected Donnelly could be held through the weekend, giving his family time to seek help related to his mental health. The solicitor’s office said deputies left the property before that could happen.

Authorities were called to the residence a third time not long afterward when Donnelly was found dead inside the small outbuilding. Prosecutors said Morgan had left the scene by then. He remained missing until two days later, when authorities located him coming out of wooded land near his home.

During an interview with investigators, Morgan admitted shooting his stepson several times, according to the solicitor’s office. Prosecutors said he acknowledged taking matters into his own hands. The official release also said Morgan told investigators that he fired a final shot because he believed he was ending Donnelly’s suffering. The killing occurred in June 2021, but the case did not reach a jury until more than five years later.

Deputy Solicitor Yates Brown and Assistant Solicitor Madison Hoffman prosecuted the case with assistance from an Eighth Circuit investigator and victim advocate. Morgan was represented at trial by attorneys Rose Mary Parham, Shipp Daniel and Ray Chandler, according to the solicitor’s office.

Eighth Circuit Solicitor David M. Stumbo said after sentencing that Morgan had “hunted down and killed a family member” after growing tired of dealing with Donnelly’s mental health symptoms. Stumbo said Donnelly deserved compassion from his family and praised prosecutors and Greenwood County sheriff’s investigators for securing the conviction.

Local reporting citing South Carolina prison records said Morgan was transferred to a state correctional facility on Nov. 19, one day after his conviction and sentencing. With parole unavailable under the sentence announced by prosecutors, he is expected to serve the full 30-year term imposed by the court.