Mom of 4 Found Dead Hanging From Tree

A judge found insufficient evidence to move forward against one of three men charged in the 29-year-old Mississippi woman’s death.

JACKSON, Miss. — A murder case against one of three men charged in the death of Tasia Fortune has been returned to Jackson police for additional investigation after a judge found there was not enough evidence to proceed against him at a preliminary hearing.

Hinds County Judge Johnnie McDaniels made the decision Tuesday during a hearing for Earnest Lloyd Jr., 25, who was arrested Sept. 22 and charged with murder in Fortune’s death. Prosecutors said the case was not ready to be presented to a grand jury. The ruling represents a significant setback in an investigation that has drawn national attention since Fortune, 29, was found dead Aug. 3 behind a vacant house in Jackson.

Fortune was found hanging from a tree in the 500 block of Road of Remembrance. Mississippi’s medical examiner later classified her death as a homicide, but authorities have not publicly disclosed the exact cause of death. Fortune’s death certificate lists the manner as homicide by unspecified means, according to her mother, Christy Spivey, who has said she still has not received clear answers about how her daughter died.

Lloyd did not attend Tuesday’s hearing because he was being transferred from a jail in northern Mississippi to the Hinds County Detention Center, according to the Associated Press and WAPT. His attorney, Nicholas Coleman, had not been able to speak with him before the hearing, the AP reported. State Public Defender Andre de Gruy, whose office does not represent Lloyd, said that when evidence is insufficient at a preliminary hearing, a case can be dismissed without prejudice, allowing investigators to continue working and prosecutors to potentially bring charges again later.

Jackson police public information officer Tommie Brown declined to comment to the AP on the judge’s decision. The ruling does not end the broader investigation into Fortune’s death. Two other men, Jarques Ratliff, 51, and Eric Clark, 45, remained jailed on murder charges in the case. All three men charged in Fortune’s death are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

Police previously said they believed the scene where Fortune was found had been staged. Jackson Police Chief RaShall Brackney said investigators believed the case stemmed from a drug dispute and that items at the scene were placed there as part of an effort to stage the circumstances surrounding Fortune’s death. Authorities have not publicly released the complete evidence supporting those allegations, and the investigation remains active.

The discovery of Fortune’s body caused widespread concern because of Mississippi’s history of racial violence and lynching. Fortune was Black, as are the three men who have been charged. Some public officials called for a federal civil rights investigation after her death. Spivey, who is white and said Fortune’s father is Black, previously told the AP that she did not believe her daughter was killed because of her race. She said she believed the circumstances were personal and involved someone who knew Fortune.

Fortune was a Kentucky native and mother of four who had lived in Jackson for about a decade, according to her family. Spivey has said her daughter had experienced homelessness in recent years but had talked about starting a cleaning business and making changes in her life. The family’s search for answers has continued through multiple arrests, court hearings and shifting developments in the investigation.

Spivey attended Tuesday’s hearing and expressed frustration afterward with the investigation and the amount of information provided to her family. She told AZFamily and Gray News that she still did not know exactly how her daughter died and had not been able to review the autopsy. She also questioned whether the Jackson Police Department had enough investigative resources to handle the city’s homicide caseload.

Police first arrested Ratliff in September after the medical examiner classified Fortune’s death as a homicide. Lloyd was arrested later that month, followed by Clark. Investigators have said they interviewed numerous people, collected forensic evidence and pursued multiple leads. Earlier court proceedings included allegations about how Fortune died and how her body came to be at the scene, but Tuesday’s finding showed that the evidence presented against Lloyd was not sufficient to move his case forward at this stage.

The case against Lloyd is now back with the Jackson Police Department for further investigation. Ratliff and Clark continue to face murder charges, while the exact cause of Fortune’s death has not been publicly released. No new timetable has been announced for when investigators might complete additional work in Lloyd’s case or whether prosecutors will seek to bring it before a grand jury later.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.